[Ndn-interest] [Possible Malware Message]Re: A synopsis of NDN

[Michael Hucka]

Hi Dr. Zhang,

Thank you very much for your comments!  With respect to the spec, you're right, I was mostly working from publications and not directly from that spec.  I'll take a look at it and try to make any necessary updates.

With respect to the second item, thanks for the pointer to the panel report.  It will be interesting to see your other forthcoming report, too.  I definitely have the sense that NDN could support these cases.

Best regards,
MH

On Fri, 30 Mar 2018 22:06:27 -0700, Lixia Zhang wrote:
> Hi Michael,
> 
> thanks for writing up the synopsis. Will read and comment when I get 
> more time. for now 2 quick comments:
> 1/ it seems that the synopsis was written before the recent NDN spec update
> 
> 2/ you wrote "Additional technical challenges enter into the picture 
> when mobile and transiently-connected elements are involved, which 
> has led to many active areas of work today in such things as mobile 
> ad hoc networks (MANET) and delay tolerant networks (DTN). How are 
> these related to decentralized content-oriented networks? Can current 
> efforts such as NDN and IPFS support mobility and delays?"
> 
> Those are good questions. 
> To the last one: I need to read more about IPFS, but I can answer the 
> NDN part with "yes".  
> I had planned to explain, as I see it, the relation between ad hoc 
> mobile, DTN and NDN as I see it in an panel report for ICN-SRA 16 
> (http://secure-web.cisco.com/1qPYzbPtrHoRhnbbetKsRgPdvjUkMv6WKbs23omWmMOKz7_ZDOCdw4lzbfcBTHUWmwNb-jiYryG4Q5CQOGYIZidUqdgRwkLNkfgQyAU4zctT70e16C6dk1kGAuJ1X_XscXQsCYCC_PO9pYGtoP9U-mGhJfKukBBA5ZY6nFQMFjuRvO1qZ-J5oD0mKv7Fs1e9ALvVviQ609Mj2hqYUQsfqqxopSCOi09WuIIvpjlPFTbuWb1aM7kuCzCIhLgFryVMpQbEwoFXBK_GB6LyF4a3aLbSRY8xjKffeS8sW0aUx5F1cVRmwfhSUnQJQoS-81_buhVQgMK0IaceyTbL-4BylfnD85bvAMJUefGDC1nrtKTPxBf779EaNY7Af-7JkbqRi/http%3A%2F%2Ficnsra.nz.comm.waseda.ac.jp%2F%3Fpage_id%3D61 
> <http://secure-web.cisco.com/1qPYzbPtrHoRhnbbetKsRgPdvjUkMv6WKbs23omWmMOKz7_ZDOCdw4lzbfcBTHUWmwNb-jiYryG4Q5CQOGYIZidUqdgRwkLNkfgQyAU4zctT70e16C6dk1kGAuJ1X_XscXQsCYCC_PO9pYGtoP9U-mGhJfKukBBA5ZY6nFQMFjuRvO1qZ-J5oD0mKv7Fs1e9ALvVviQ609Mj2hqYUQsfqqxopSCOi09WuIIvpjlPFTbuWb1aM7kuCzCIhLgFryVMpQbEwoFXBK_GB6LyF4a3aLbSRY8xjKffeS8sW0aUx5F1cVRmwfhSUnQJQoS-81_buhVQgMK0IaceyTbL-4BylfnD85bvAMJUefGDC1nrtKTPxBf779EaNY7Af-7JkbqRi/http%3A%2F%2Ficnsra.nz.comm.waseda.ac.jp%2F%3Fpage_id%3D61>) 
> panel on "Application of ICN in Infrastructure-Free Environments: 
> Rural Areas, Disaster Recovery, and Military Tactical Environments",
> but didn't manage to finish it quickly, so I gave up. Your comment 
> made me believe that report is still worth finishing, however late it 
> is.
> 
> more later,
> Lixia
> 
>> On Mar 30, 2018, at 12:25 PM, Michael Hucka <mhucka at caltech.edu> wrote:
>> 
>> Hello,
>> 
>> As part of some recent research work, I wrote a synopsis of NDN and 
>> collected all the literature I could find about it.  If anyone is 
>> interested in seeing the materials, they can be found at 
>> https://secure-web.cisco.com/1iJAYpw2551Dd1LJiEKUY17Yd7omkNM2U__2tHZSHZNfQOoHV-foPc8TZQAUD4ZarGEc5B5mtgoY5pa4Kn26FN44jMNscs6RgR2N5y8TyB-_sM_QtvkezbQ7oEmpU_NhpXltqMdrCP_HX2Z2nMKvwUgQFXF5NfmL9vbWBg4qtjxOz-J4q7Z5mLSach3EHVhVNoVcgt3AFvmKYXleMNOF2VDTNdV7ZTvRcSMRakBhm-_VDp1hUggNMVbfKLK1yzUsgalH4tA6lIAMja1iTrbZ7_WrC4drnaciZGGTZj1DAvT874yUc-UzQwFydjl5G44dMpF9NG88k7ZoGzfmpDr3OzHSFuGTta_eXLfhyz1MQlm9xu1xqwW7B3wxP6SH7LHdT/https%3A%2F%2Fmhucka.github.io%2Fdcons%2F.  
>> I will happily accept corrections and suggestions -- I did my best, 
>> but I'm sure there are mistakes.
>> 
>> My hope is to do more in the area of decentralized networking in the 
>> near future, and write more technical summaries along the way.  One 
>> topic I'd like to investigate is how NDN relates to IPFS.  Any 
>> pointers about information regarding that would be welcome!
>> 
>> Best regards,
>> MH
>> --
>> Mike Hucka, Ph.D. -- mhucka at caltech.edu -- 
>> http://secure-web.cisco.com/1mEcLqxgxRbTYEwuf-xwylJC9eRU-1SdLbjzmtG1xLa5FdZMYtrVSnaRVJ1iFFgMVxCw6Ae1iA0Zsswu55-4Xtm1EHxpY1A4pCP1MkzI15BqODzrvxD_r4TBwAyykO7zIHstR_3PLOxoHKQFKftIvX3Ymjp62NeDd7tb5eprUIYEeimL68jYJTGEaF-cJRcfaIHLFF8gvI7sIrZhNQ3hkcA6ODRr4Jjocqpnn0B2VNrbg_MLxlDze4xZm3jDXKvvgEQCiI_w6JvcyGe8jk3C92hD756e3afNlBlttr8RVBjGWgUe5NK5yW0_HPo2Q2FCwUTUmwFTmTMe7ppxC3EjSmcUP7G8wtDXmMtUkN6WQDAaI0YyNDEh6dxpa3CO2GMN3/http%3A%2F%2Fwww.cds.caltech.edu%2F%7Emhucka
>> Dept. of Computing + Mathematical Sciences, California Institute of 
>> Technology
>> _______________________________________________
>> Ndn-interest mailing list
>> Ndn-interest at lists.cs.ucla.edu
>> http://secure-web.cisco.com/1gfkVBNfy08IO9kZ6O0AEzN25zrCJXxsW-WzMY88XIT7r_HuEysun0otu185n9xq_aIrqFp-S9s_MJdY80CMbLuUpcnagUb8I2fd_4tN1cfPEFt84_XTQO0JA6bay-f-IdEaSGYSZgJ0NCQSeEHz7u9zqr8KYQQttIzUnZiRB88FZFl6zd0aaLQ8br60qWJdHa0qPLdBaJCx4WN6WvTwo8zyTJHMWUsWPPGfNg8O-FVtqVvVNBcFtaKnXbH8ZM_kGYAkMMEl-6a82Q4Uc6Ic_Eym1DOCbIkknTjt7lYl5PM5rh4fVGXN6ED09ksaxwmGIrCvl2A4mhuV-VGzIeu8A-DRzkU7e6rUWZjohq0ocSrNF8wCbOOIMIhVZf6vHIyF3/http%3A%2F%2Fwww.lists.cs.ucla.edu%2Fmailman%2Flistinfo%2Fndn-interest
>